top of page

Welcome to Sarah Cookies

 

What started out as a cookie care package has turned into a cookie making adventure.

I'm sharing my love for cookies and other baked confections here, and I hope you enjoy!

Orange Crinkle Cookies

Makes 2 dozen I've been on a cookie hiatus, but was lured back to create a special cookie for the middle sister's baby shower. I had made...

Breakfast Bites

Makes 2 dozen One time, way back when we all still went places to have fun with large groups of people, my now-husband and I attended...

My Samoas

Makes about 2 dozen For the first cookie of 2021, I went back to the one that started this project a few years ago. A sister had just...

Inception Cookies

Makes about 3 dozen Husband has dubbed these "Inception Cookies," but you can call them what you want. Really they are cookies and cream...

Orange & Carrot No-Bakes

Makes about 2 dozen There are many problems with this cookie, the first being that it may not actually be a cookie. This was my first...

Jam Tarts

Makes about 3 dozen Summer is gone, so I thought a nice way to end the season would be to make these jam tart cookies to highlight summer...

Cookie Dough Truffles

Makes about 3 dozen I've made cookie dough truffles before and they are definitely a good low-bake option for the hot weather we've been...

Sarah Cookies

Makes about 5 dozen cookies Next to my mom's peanut butter cookies, this recipe represents my earliest food memory and is one of my go-to...

Strawberry Sandwich Cookies

Makes about 2 dozen sandwiches The base of this cookie is my all-time favorite, but I cannot for the life of me remember where I got the...

Piña Colada Cookies

Makes 3 dozen When we first moved into our house we did not have an oven or stove top. For about six months everything was cooked using a...

Cottontails

Makes 3 dozen I normally only make these cookies at Christmas, traditionally in crescent shapes. The prospect of being stuck indoors on...

Banana Coconut Muffins

Makes 12 muffins We bought too many bananas! Rather than let the overripe ones go to waste, I transformed them into breakfast. We'll be...

Blueberry Oatmeal Cookies

Makes about 3 dozen After baking for other people yesterday, husband requested I make some cookies just for us and handed me the bag of...

Pignoli

Makes about 5 dozen Another recipe from grandma. It took a little while to get these to taste like my memory of the ones she always made...

Grapefruit Sandwich Cookies

Makes about 4 dozen (2 dozen sandwiches) I can say with almost absolute certainty that you have stockpiled an excessive amount of citrus...

Tomato Soup Cake

Makes 1 8 x 8 cake I know, it's not a cookie, but these are desperate times. If you're not keen on heading to the grocery right now, you...

Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies

Makes about 3 dozen I was in a very peanut mood. INGREDIENTS 1/2 c vegetable shortening 1/2 c super chunky peanut butter 1/2 c packed...

Chocolate Butter Cookies

Makes 3-4 dozen So chocolate. INGREDIENTS 20 Tbsp (2 1/2 sticks) unsalted butter, softened to room temp 1/2 c cocoa powder 1 tsp instant...

Almond & Pignoli Macaroons

Makes 2-3 dozen A cookie for your coffee. Not overly swee INGREDIENTS 1 1/4 c whole almonds (unsalted) 2/3 c pignoli (pine nuts) 1 1/2...

1
2
bottom of page